The National Science Foundation Walks Back a Destructive Proposal, but Danger Persists

November 16, 2026 | 10:14 am
A woman in a scientific lab examines samplesNational Cancer Institute/Unsplash
Kei Koizumi
Senior Advisor

The National Science Foundation (NSF) is one of the most important scientific institutions in the world, supporting US science, engineering, technology, and innovation since its inception in 1950. Back in July, I wrote about the value of NSF and why we need to defend it. At the time, its leadership role in science was under threat: NSF had just proposed major changes in how it would award research grants. These proposed rules—which were open for public comment—would have destroyed NSF’s merit review procedures. UCS, along with scientists and scientific organizations across the country, spoke up against these proposals.

The good news: our efforts worked, for now. Thanks to comments from us and thousands of others, NSF earlier this month responded to the comments and stepped back from many of the most damaging proposals, as I describe below. But we’re not out of the woods yet. The still-active 119th Congress is back in Washington, DC, this week for some unfinished business before the newly-elected Congress takes office in January. We’re hoping this unfinished business includes permanently stopping the damaging OMB-proposed changes to government-wide grants policies that were paused until December 11, as well as making decisions on final funding levels for science programs for federal fiscal year 2027.

But there’s another danger on the horizon. The Senate Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions (HELP) Committee has scheduled a vote on November 18 to advance the nomination Jim O’Neill, the Trump administration’s unqualified nominee to be NSF Director. This timing matters, because if O’Neill is not confirmed by the end of the year, the administration will have to re-submit his nomination to the incoming Senate—with a new majority—next year. We’re calling on the UCS community to urge Senators to vote NO on confirming Jim O’Neill as NSF Director. 

How our comments protected NSF

Before we get to the challenges that still lie ahead, let’s take stock of how our voices were heard at NSF.

As I said before, although two dozen US federal agencies fund some form of research and development (R&D), NSF is the only federal agency charged in its original legislation with supporting research at the frontiers of knowledge across all science and engineering disciplines. Since 1950, NSF has been investing in research and research infrastructure, as well as STEM education across the nation, primarily through universities via research and education grants. NSF uses a merit-based review process to allocate nearly all of its funding and to ensure that proposals it receives “are reviewed in a fair, competitive, transparent and in-depth manner.”

NSF has stepped back from the administration’s proposal of requiring political appointee review of all its awards. The original July proposal would have subjected all NSF awards, meaning everything—not just research grants but also fellowships, training grants, center grants, and undergraduate research opportunities—to review and approval by a politically-appointed official before being issued. This review would have put every grant under the political microscope, through an unspecified process and under unspecified criteria, in contradiction to everything NSF’s current merit-review process stands for. Many of us commented that such political review would be destructive not just to individual grants but to the entire US science and engineering enterprise. That proposed layer of political review comes from the OMB’s government-wide Guidance for Financial Assistance, which was paused by Congress through December 11. Many of us commented that because that OMB rule is not final, it was wildly premature for NSF to incorporate its provisions into its own policies. In its public response, NSF basically agreed, stating that the agency would not be changing its merit review policies to incorporate OMB’s policy of political review at this time. 

The July NSF proposal would also have incorporated OMB’s policy changes that would disallow funds from supporting travel to scientific conferences or publication costs of research publications. At the time, I wrote that if a federal agency determines that research is worthy of federal support with public dollars, they should support not only the experiment but also the publication and public presentation of the research results. Communicating research results is an integral part of research. Again, our comments appear to have worked, because NSF has stated it will keep supporting conference travel or publication costs as allowable costs in awards (while the final fate of the OMB regulation is being considered).

NSF also partially, but not completely, walked back its proposal to stop supporting all research collaborations with certain countries, including the People’s Republic of China (PRC). The original proposal, because it incorporated OMB’s pending regulation, would have placed a blanket prohibition on federally-funded researchers collaborating with any researchers from a covered country or entity, starting with China (including both US scientists at Chinese institutions and US-trained Chinese scientists).

I and other commenters pointed out that the US scientific enterprise is strengthened by the fact that scientists here can collaborate with the best scientists from around the world, including China, on areas where there is little to no risk for national security, especially for research that is intended to be published in the open literature. Putting aside thoughtful risk mitigation and instead prohibiting any and all collaboration with countries or entities on a list, does great damage to US science. The revised NSF proposal has some restrictions on international collaborations, but not on entire countries. The revised proposal incorporates a Dear Colleague letter on Prohibition on Collaborations with Restricted Entities published in August which links to lists of “proscribed parties.” NSF would not fund researchers and projects collaborating with entities and institutions on these lists. These lists include many (but by no means all) Chinese universities and other research institutions. It seems that our comments saying a blanket ban on US scientists collaborating with a nation’s entire research community would hurt US science have been heard.

The danger persists

Although we can take comfort in the small victories so far, we’re not done, because NSF is still in peril, even beyond the grant terminations, canceled centers, diverted funding, the firing of the entire National Science Board, and unspent congressional appropriations we’ve seen over the past year and a half.

Leadership matters, and we can’t let a lame-duck Congress rush through a new leader who could undermine NSF. UCS and other organizations are on record calling Jim O’Neill unqualified, an “unacceptable choice,” and “an egregious nominee,” in part because of his record of pushing for more political control and political review over science. The US Senate should vote NO on O’Neill. 

Beyond the potential confirmation of a new director, there’s a lot at stake for NSF in coming weeks. If the OMB proposal were to become final policy after the current pause, these harmful policies would go into effect. NSF would be forced to implement political review, end conference travel and publications support, and ban entire countries from collaborations. Just last week, a group of scientists and science organizations sued NSF over its de facto shuttering of NSF’s Directorate for Social, Behavioral and Economic Sciences (SBE) and the zero awards it has granted over the past year in many SBE disciplines, against the explicit instructions laid out by Congress. And NSF is temporarily funded at last year’s (2026) levels through December 11, while this Congress continues to deliberate on the President’s 2027 budget proposal to cut NSF’s budget by 55 percent.

It’s often said and it’s as true now as ever: the work of democracy is never done. The November midterm elections are now behind us (although some votes are still being counted). But we still have work to do to preserve the important role NSF plays in US science and engineering. If NSF’s long tradition of supporting leading-edge scientific research and education, based primarily on merit review, is as important to you as it is to me, I hope you’ll make your voices heard and urge your Senators to vote NO on O’Neill. We can take strength from the impact we’ve had so far and stay ready for the next steps to keep our democracy and our science and engineering enterprise strong.